Ripping the Visual Studio Editor Apart with Projection Buffers

Introduction to Projection Buffers

I’d like to preface this by thanking Jason Malinowski for his help navigating projection buffers.

One could go a lifetime writing Visual Studio extensions and be forgiven for not understanding or using Visual Studio’s projection buffers. They’re mentioned only briefly on MSDN, and Microsoft has yet to release any samples on how to use them properly.

Projection buffers allow us to create composite editors from different source buffers and are used in ASP .Net’s Razor pages that interlace HTML and C#/VB.Net. They can also be used to subset a buffer, and display only this subset to the user. At Code Connect, we’ve used them to display files on a function-by-function basis.

Projection buffers make cool things like this possible:

Today, we’ll be looking at the steps to embed two editors within a Visual Studio Tool Window, one with an original source file and the other with a projection of the first.

Note: This guide is for Visual Studio 2013 + Roslyn. The C#/VB.Net Language Services were largely re-written and their interaction with projection buffers has evolved and changed. As with all Visual Studio extensions, you’ll also need the Visual Studio SDK.

You can download the complete project from Github:

Step-by-Step Guide

1. Create a new Visual Studio Package with a Tool Window. I’ve named mine ProjectionBufferTutorial.

2. Let Visual Studio know you’ll define a MEF export by following these steps:

  • Open source.extension.vsixmanifest in Solution Explorer
  • Click Assets
  • Click New
  • Set Type to: Microsoft.VisualStudio.MefComponent
  • Set Source to: A project in current solution
  • Set Project to: ProjectionBufferTutorial (or whatever you’ve named your project)
  • Click OK
  • Save

3. Right click your project and add references to:Microsoft.VisualStudio.Editor.dll

  • Microsoft.VisualStudio.Text.UI.Wpf.dll
  • Microsoft.VisualStudio.Text.UI.dll
  • Microsoft.VisualStudio.Text.Data.dll
  • Microsoft.VisualStudio.Text.Logic.dll
  • Microsoft.VisualStudio.CoreUtility.dll
  • Microsoft.VisualStudio.ComponentModelHost.dll
  • System.ComponentModel.Composition.dll

4. Modify MyControl.xaml to contain the following code. This creates two content controls, one for the entire file and one for a subset of the file.

5. Add the following static class VisualStudioServices.cs to your project. This allows us to interface with a number of services within Visual Studio.

6. Modify ProjectionBufferTutorialPackage.cs (or <YourName>Package.cs) to contain the following. This initializes the various static Visual Studio services for us to use.

7. Add the following code to MyToolWindow.cs. The amount of boilerplate is an absolutely astonishing, but necessary evil. This class creates two WpfTextViewHosts representing the full file. However, it attaches the custom role “CustomProjectionRole” to one. It then adds start position and end position properties to the text buffer. We’ll use these to define the range of text we’d like to project.

Note: Make sure to modify filePath to point to a valid C# file on your machine.

Note: DO NOT OVERWRITE THE GUID AT THE TOP OF YOUR CLASS. This Guid is randomly generated and stored in Guids.cs. These two must match, therefore make sure to use your own.

8. Finally, add a new file to the project called ProjectionTextViewModelProvider.cs.  This class listens for the creation of WpfTextViews with the role “CustomProjectionRole”. It then modifies the visual buffer to display only a subset of the original file.

Important: Point the private string filePath to a valid C# file on your file system. Run the project.

9. Open the solution containing your chosen file. Click View > Other Windows > ProjectionBufferTutorial (or whatever you’ve named your project)

A tool window will open containing two files, the right being a subset of the first. As you make changes to one, the changes are instantly reflected in the other. All Language Services should be working.


I’d first like to hedge this section by saying I don’t work at Microsoft. These APIs are largely undocumented with no samples available on how to correctly use them. My usage of ITextViewModelProvider and various other Visual Studio services borders on cargo cult programming.

That being said, this is my understanding of what’s happening.


There’s a lot going on here. For starters, our class inherits from IOleCommandTarget. An entire blog post could (and should) be written on this interface and commanding within Visual Studio. Here’s my quick-and-dirty take on this.

Visual Studio uses the command chain design pattern to route commands. Essentially, a linked list is created of different components (all inheriting from IOleCommandTarget) that are interested in listening to commands. Basic commands include arrow key presses, Ctr-Z, and backspace. For just a sampling of the many possible commands see VSConstants.VSStd97CmdID.

When a command is received by a command filter object, it can do one of the following:

  • Handle the command and pass the command down the chain.
  • Handle the command and do not pass the command down the chain.
  • Do not handle the command, and pass it down the chain.
  • Ignore the command completely and not pass it down the chain.

The IOleCommandTarget.Query() method is fired before the command is actually passed down the chain. This method simply probes the chain to see if anyone can even handle the command.

The IOleCommandTarget.Exec() method is fired when the command can be handled. The command is passed down the chain, handled and then an error code is returned. If no error was encountered, the value 0 is returned.

MyToolWindow inherits from IOleCommandTarget and routes commands (backspace, arrow keys, Ctr-Space etc.) to the IVsTextView of the editor.

The other major workhorse within MyToolWindow is CreateEditor(). This method creates an IVsInvisibleEditor for a given filepath. This IVsInvisibleEditor takes care of a lot of background work not relevant to this blog post, including registering the file within the Running Document Table.

We then retrieve the IVsTextLines from this IVsInvisibleEditor and use it to create a new IVsCodeWindow. I believe this code window represents the dual-pane editor we use in Visual Studio when working with any code files. (All code windows are dual pane, drag the slider above the vertical scrollbar if you’re unsure what I’m talking about). Below is a screen shot of a dual-pane window:


After setting the content of this dual-pane window, we can set the roles for it. Common roles include “DOCUMENT” and “ZOOMABLE”. Manipulating these roles allows us to change properties of the code window. For example, we can omit “ZOOMABLE” and remove the ability for the user to zoom in and out. We can also add custom roles, which we’ve done here. We’ve added “CustomProjectionRole” to the text buffer. This will allow us to handle this buffer different in the future and distinguish it from other C# buffers that may have been created by Visual Studio or another plugin.

Finally, we convert the IVsTextView to a IWpfTextViewHost, and object we can embed within typical WPF elements.


There are two classes defined here, ProjectionTextViewModelProvider, and the actual ProjectionTextViewModel that we are providing. The provider’s sole responsibility is to wait for C# text buffers to be created with the role “CustomProjectionRole”. When this happens, it creates a custom view of the buffer to be displayed to the user. It does this by creating a projection buffer and a ProjectionTextViewModel that uses this projection buffer as its VisualBuffer. When VisualStudio goes to display a WpfTextView to a user, it uses the contents of the VisualBuffer.

It’s worth noting that we’ve MEF imported the IProjectionBufferFactoryService (what a majestic name…) in order to create our projection buffer. If you’ve never used MEF before, this will look like magic. (It still does to me).

Hopefully this is enough to get most people started with projection buffers. If you feel overwhelmed, don’t worry, that’s completely natural. One of the unfortunate realities of Visual Studio extensions is that there are an ungodly number of moving parts. The only way to ever hope to understand what is going on is to get your hands dirty. Take this project and start taking things apart and breaking it. You’ll gradually grow more comfortable with the many interfaces and how they interact with one another.

Finally, check out how we’re using this stuff in Code Connect and follow me on Twitter.

12 thoughts on “Ripping the Visual Studio Editor Apart with Projection Buffers

    1. That’s awesome. I think it would help if you showed some screenshots of it in action on GitHub. Congratulations on getting this far, working with Visual Studio extensions is pretty difficult.

  1. Hi, first of all thanks for the awesome tutorial, secondly, i’ve been trying to make an extension by following your tutorial, it uses a custom editor for specific file types in our projects, however my code window doesn’t respond to keyboard input, the extension is for vs2015, could you give me some suggestions on what to do?

      1. Yeah, the editor shows up, and the file displays correctly. I tried debugging the IOleCommandTarget section, it seems that the exec and the query status methods respond to arrow keys, but not to the alphabetical keys. they both don’t have any effect on the editor window whatsoever, using the arrow keys won’t move the cursor, i’ll try checking a bit more on the code, Thanks

  2. Hi I am not sure if this still active, I have tried this solution to create a code editor but for some reason the keyboard events are not passing correctly to the editor text.
    For example if I use the arrows it will behave like tab (passing between the text to the zoom in the bar)
    also when I click on diagnostics or find results the cursor does not move to the position (or the scroll).
    When I attach the VsCode directly using an Editor factory it works.

    Hope that after all this time this can still be answered.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s